“ Show me the incentive — and I’ll show you the outcome”
Some of us are aware of this
We’re aware of this in business, politics
We’re now aware of this on social media
the cobra effect
algorithmic boosting of outrage and dumbing down of entertainment
etc
now, there’s one that maybe eludes our perception
it’s the INCENTIVE TO BE STUPID
because
the incentive to please your audience
the incentive to please an important person
are all a clear case of the dissolution of moral standards for personal gain
with the gain often being relegated to subconsciousness, or vaguely rationalised
but the incentive to be stupid?
what gain is there in being stupid?
well it’s the same gain as with the gain from being corrupt,
when you think about it — being upright is usually the preferred, LOGICAL strategy
you build better, more enduring relationships, you don’t get into trouble with others and/or with the law, you are given greater responsibility on account of your greater trustworthiness and track record, etc
yet we still break those rules, because we figure out that perhaps this is a LOGICAL exception
well,
why shouldn’t there be a LOGICAL EXCEPTION to BEING LOGICAL? To being coherent, intelligent, nuanced, thoughtful?
So the obvious case is obviously the dumbing down of our culture
The dumbing down of the public discourse
The dumbing down of the intellectual standards
The dumbing down of the competence
…and of course, predictably, it all ends up with incompetence
And then we turn to experts again,
to institutions again,
to credentialism again
because we just want shit to work, again
but this is not merely about it
with incentive to be corrupt — there’s of course rationalisation — but there is not necessarily the assumption that this person has always been corrupt
whereas with INTELLIGENCE — the incentive to be STUPID causes INTELLIGENT people to be regarded as FOOLS
the INCENTIVE is not part of the consideration
this is the interesting observation
now,
What is intelligence/stupidity?
Is it our raw intellectual capability?
Or is it the result after all of our experiences, education, incentives?
Is it what we do, and what’s coming out of our mouths, that matters more than our capabilities in the abstract?
I would of course reckon that the final product is what matters
I don’t care why you’re being so fucking stupid
And if you are so well educated, or people told you that you’re so smart, or you WAS precocious, or maybe you are more successful, or maybe you’re such a great debater, blablabla
If you say stupid shit, and especially if you do stupid shit — you’re a fucking fool to me
And I don’t care if you were INCENTIVISED to be so fucking stupid
You’re still a fool to me
At the same time, knowing how COMPLEX intelligence and wisdom and judgement and clarity are — I don’t rule out the possibility of you nevertheless having respectable cognitive potential,
and knowing the incentive — I can even imagine that, sans this incentive — it is still quite formidable
And INDEED, incentives are quite arbitrary,
We may choose to devote more cognitive resources to given challenge,
we may choose to be more curious, educate ourselves more,
but do we CHOOSE OUR INCENTIVES?
Or do we just want to live a good life — and follow whichever path seems to get us there?
So in that case, there’s a bit of MORAL LUCK involved, with you encountering JUST THE RIGHT INCENTIVES — that will be conducive to your intellectual, epistemic development
I consider this the final interesting observation
To be smart, judicious, wise — you have to get lucky twice:
-have the baseline cognitive capacity
-AND be incentivized to actually TRACK REALITY — and develop adequate information-processing toolkit
Of course, now that we identified incentive as a real threat to your epistemology,
we can be more MINDFUL of the consequences of certain incentives
PERHAPS that game, which requires you to be a bit less informed, nuanced, thoughtful, creative — is NOT the best game to spend life playing
Finally,
perhaps merely removing that incentive WILL change the outcome
Verily, in a better society — perhaps even an ugly person is a paragon of virtue
And verily, perhaps a lot of FOOLS around you — are not exactly so fucking STUPID — in a society that has more respect for education, raw intelligence and brilliant track record: in action and in forecasting
Therefore show some empathy
Maybe not everyone is as stupid as they sound, when they regurgitate stupid shit WITHOUT thinking
And maybe you’re not so stupid either