There can be one compelling HYPOTHESIS… or a BUNCH of compelling hypothesis
-doesn’t mean that one is right
-doesn’t mean ANY of those many are right
We know something to be right because it’s not only COMPELLING and LOGICAL — but also it’s WELL TESTED
–PREFERABLY IN REAL WORLD, EMPIRICALLY
-but subjected to POWERFUL CRITICISM will do if former is unavailable
Alas there are subjects where we REALLY WANT TO HAVE AN OPINION — but don’t have ability or resources or willingness to do ALL THE NECESSARY TESTINGS and CRITIQUING
subjects where we really care about the outcome
This is the very root of WISHFUL THINKING
Thus,
Our WISHFUL THINKING and fucking DELUSION is directly proportional to:
-perceived RELEVANCE of the subject
-complexity and OPAQUENESS of the subject
-existence of a COMPELLING HYPOTHESIS
-our COGNITIVE LIMITATIONS
-and general INTELLECTUAL and spiritual INSINCERITY
Indeed,
RELEVANCE means DESIRE
DESIRE means you may be rather reluctant to give up your fantasies,
which give meaning to your life,
which gratify you, give you pleasure
You may rather prefer it over reality
You may rather prefer it over being right
Over logic and evidence
indeed
The more COMPLICATED the subject, and the LESSER your INTELLECTUAL TOOLS — the less likely you are to PENETRATE IT and acquire UNDERSTANDING
And the less likely you are to even realise just how CLUELESS you are (Dunning Kruger effect)
Finally, add the final utterly DESTABILISING INGREDIENT:
COMPELLING HYPOTHESIS
So that, despite having found no real proof, having only scratched the surface of the deep lake — you yet manage to go home with something
You yet manage to believe something
And you want to believe
Combine those,
and you have a recipe for DELUSION
This is a great formula
Because we can reverse engineer it
And protect OURSELVES from delusion
And even REVERSE it, perhaps
This is a great formula
-Use it on yourself, to realise when you’re PRONE to SELF-DELUSION
-Use it on others, to realise when THEY are being delusional
-And finally, use it when CONSTRUCTING INCENTIVES — to prevent DELUSION before it even happens